The debate on media including social media on the action of a young major in Kashmir is unending. A large number of politicians, socialists, liberals, pseudo intellectuals and such like others have commented that the young man is guilty of using human shield to save his skin and colleagues. Some have even labelled it as an act of cowardice. Interestingly, everyone seems to know what a young major should not have done while encountering a hostile, offensive and armed crowd of over thousand people. A stone is also an arm when it is being or intended to be used as one. However, sadly, none of them has a clue or suggested an alternate course of action that was available to the officer to tackle the vexed situation he confronted and its contingent fallout. Here, there is an inherent problem. Illiterate and grossly unfit people know whether, when and how a doctor should operate. Masons and Mechanics know better designs of bridges than engineers. Street paddlers can give tips ...